A New Extended Analytical Hierarchy Process Technique with Incomplete Interval-valued Information for Risk Assessment in IT Outsourcing


1 Department of Industrial Engineering, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran

2 Department of Industrial Engineering and Management Systems, Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran

3 Department of Productivity and System Management, Sharif University of Technology, International Campus-Kish Island, Kish, Iran


Information technology (IT) outsourcing has been recognized as a new methodology in many organizations. Yet making an appropriate decision with regard to selection and use of these methodologies may impose uncertainties and risks. Estimating the occurrence probability of risks and their impacts organizations goals may reduce their threats. In this study, an extended analytical hierarchical process method is tailored based on interval-valued hesitant fuzzy information to assess the risks in IT outsourcing. In the proposed approach, the weight of each decision maker is implemented in process of the proposed method by considering the concept of simple additive weighting method to decrease the judgment errors. In addition, the opinions of each decision maker about the risks of IT outsourcing under the conflicted attributes are aggregated in final step of the proposed procedure to reduce the data loss. Indeed, this paper proposes a new extended interval-valued hesitant fuzzy final aggregation analytical hierarchical process by considering the decision makers' importance. Finally, an adopted case study in ISACO corporation as the largest spare parts deliverer in Iran is considered to indicate the process implementation of the proposed approach. In this respect, the risks and their factors in the domain of IT outsourcing are identified based on experts’ judgments. Therefore, the achieved ranking results indicate that the proposed approach could deal with group decision-making problem as a reliable manner.


1.     Clemons, E. K. and Hitt, L. M., "Strategic sourcing for services: Assessing the balance between outsourcing and insourcing", Operations and Information Management Working Paper, (1997), 97-06.

2.     Lee, J.-N., Huynh, M. Q., Kwok, R. C.-W. and Pi, S.-M., "It outsourcing evolution---: Past, present, and future", Communications of the ACM,  Vol. 46, No. 5, (2003), 84-89.

3.     Bharadwaj, A. S., "A resource-based perspective on information technology capability and firm performance: An empirical investigation", MIS Quarterly,  Vol., 24, No., 1, (2000), 169-196.

4.     Mathew, S. K., "Understanding risk in it outsourcing: A fuzzy framework", Journal of Information Technology Case and Application Research,  Vol. 8, No. 3, (2006), 27-39.

5.     Thouin, M. F., Hoffman, J. J. and Ford, E. W., "It outsourcing and firm-level performance: A transaction cost perspective", Information & Management,  Vol. 46, No. 8, (2009), 463-469.

6.     Nakatsu, R. T. and Iacovou, C. L., "A comparative study of important risk factors involved in offshore and domestic outsourcing of software development projects: A two-panel delphi study", Information & Management,  Vol. 46, No. 1, (2009), 57-68.

7.     Aubert, B. A., Rivard, S. and Patry, M., "A transaction cost model of it outsourcing", Information & Management,  Vol. 41, No. 7, (2004), 921-932.

8.     Bahli, B. and Rivard, S., "Validating measures of information technology outsourcing risk factors", Omega,  Vol. 33, No. 2, (2005), 175-187.

9.     Park, J.-Y. and Kim, J. S., "The impact of is sourcing type on service quality and maintenance efforts", Information & Management,  Vol. 42, No. 2, (2005), 261-274.

10.   Graf, M. and Mudambi, S. M., "The outsourcing of it-enabled business processes: A conceptual model of the location decision", Journal of International Management,  Vol. 11, No. 2, (2005), 253-268.

11.   Percin, S., "Fuzzy multi-criteria risk-benefit analysis of business process outsourcing (bpo)", Information Management & Computer Security,  Vol. 16, No. 3, (2008), 213-234.

12.   Chen, L. Y. and Wang, T.-C., "Optimizing partners’ choice in is/it outsourcing projects: The strategic decision of fuzzy vikor", International Journal of Production Economics,  Vol. 120, No. 1, (2009), 233-242.

13.   Chen, L.-H. and Hung, C.-C., "An integrated fuzzy approach for the selection of outsourcing manufacturing partners in pharmaceutical r&d", International Journal of Production Research,  Vol. 48, No. 24, (2010), 7483-7506.

14.   Samantra, C., Datta, S. and Mahapatra, S. S., "Risk assessment in it outsourcing using fuzzy decision-making approach: An indian perspective", Expert Systems with Applications,  Vol. 41, No. 8, (2014), 4010-4022.

15.   Aubert, B. A., Patry, M. and Rivard, S., "Managing it outsourcing risk: Lessons learned", Springer,  (2002).

16.   Lacity, M. C., & Hirshheim R., "The information systems outsourcing bandwagon", Sloan Management Review,  Vol., 35, No., 1, (1993), 73-86.

17.   Al-Qirim, N. and Bathula, H., "It and ecommerce outsourcing in small to medium-size enterprises in new zealand: An exploratory research", BLED 2002 Proceedings, (2002).

18.   Yoon, Y. K. and Im, K. S., "Evaluating it outsourcing customer satisfaction and its impact on firm performance in korea", International Journal of Technology Management,  Vol. 43, No. 1-3, (2008), 160-175.

19.   Aubert, B. A., Patry, M. and Rivard, S., "Assessing the risk of it outsourcing", in System Sciences, Proceedings of the Thirty-First Hawaii International Conference on, IEEE, Vol. 6, (1998), 685-692.

20.   Aubert, B. A., Dussault, S., Patry, M. and Rivard, S., "Managing the risk of it outsourcing", in Systems Sciences, HICSS-32. Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Hawaii International Conference on, IEEE, (1999).

21.   Khalfan, A. M., "Information security considerations in is/it outsourcing projects: A descriptive case study of two sectors", International Journal of Information Management,  Vol. 24, No. 1, (2004), 29-42.

22.   Han, S. H., Kim, D. Y., Kim, H. and Jang, W.-S., "A web-based integrated system for international project risk management", Automation in Construction,  Vol. 17, No. 3, (2008), 342-356.

23.   Aundhe, M. D. and Mathew, S. K., "Risks in offshore it outsourcing: A service provider perspective", European Management Journal,  Vol. 27, No. 6, (2009), 418-428.

24.   Tang, X. Y., Jiang, Y. N. and Jian, J., "Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation for it project risk management", in Applied Mechanics and Materials, Trans Tech Publ, Vol. 229, (2012), 2753-2759.

25.   Prakash, S., Soni, G., Mittal, S. and Rathore, A. P. S., "Information risks modeling in e-business supply chain using AHP", in Engineering and Computational Sciences (RAECS), Recent Advances in, IEEE, (2014), 1-5.

26.   e Silva, L. C., de Gusmao, A. P. H., Silva, M. M., Poleto, T. and Costa, A. P. C. S., "Analysis of it outsourcing services failures based on an existing risk model", in Systems, Man, and Cybernetics (SMC), IEEE International Conference on, (2015), 286-290.

27.   Hamzah, A. K., "A review of it outsourcing relevant and success determinants and a proposed model", Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Technology Research,  Vol. 3, No. 3, (2013), 136-152.

28.   Hodosi, G., Manavi, S. and Rusu, L., "Risk factors in it outsourcing and the theories decision makers use to resolve them", International Journal of Social and Organizational Dynamics in IT (IJSODIT),  Vol. 3, No. 2, (2013), 41-54.

29.   Taylan, O., "It project risk assessment of learning organizations by fuzzy set and systems", International Journal of Organizational Analysis,  Vol. 22, No. 2, (2014), 161-180.

30.   Yudatama, U. and Sarno, R., "Evaluation maturity index and risk management for it governance using fuzzy ahp and fuzzy topsis (case study bank xyz)", in Intelligent Technology and Its Applications (ISITIA), International Seminar on, IEEE, (2015), 323-328.

31.   Silic, M. and Back, A., "The influence of risk factors in decision-making process for open source software adoption", International Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making,  Vol. 15, No. 01, (2016), 151-185.

32.   Aris, S. R. H. S., Arshad, N. H. and Mohamed, A., "Conceptual framework on risk management in it outsourcing projects", Management,  Vol. 36, No. 37, (2008), 37-38.

33.   Fan, Z.-P., Suo, W.-L. and Feng, B., "Identifying risk factors of it outsourcing using interdependent information: An extended dematel method", Expert Systems with Applications,  Vol. 39, No. 3, (2012), 3832-3840.

34.   Byun, D.-H., "The ahp approach for selecting an automobile purchase model", Information & Management,  Vol. 38, No. 5, (2001), 289-297.

35.   Liu, D.-R. and Shih, Y.-Y., "Integrating ahp and data mining for product recommendation based on customer lifetime value", Information & Management,  Vol. 42, No. 3, (2005), 387-400.

36.   Ngai, E., "Selection of web sites for online advertising using the ahp", Information & Management,  Vol. 40, No. 4, (2003), 233-242.

37.   Ebrahimnejad, S., Mousavi, S. M. and Mojtahedi, S. M. H., "A fuzzy decision-making model for risk ranking with an application to an onshore gas refinery", International Journal of Business Continuity and Risk Management,  Vol. 1, No. 1, (2009), 38-66.

38.   Yu, H.-C., Lee, Z.-Y. and Chang, S.-C., "Using a fuzzy multi-criteria decision making approach to evaluate alternative licensing mechanisms", Information & Management,  Vol. 42, No. 4, (2005), 517-531.

39.   Ebrahimnejad, S., Mousavi, S. M. and Seyrafianpour, H., "Risk identification and assessment for build–operate–transfer projects: A fuzzy multi attribute decision making model", Expert systems with Applications,  Vol. 37, No. 1, (2010), 575-586.

40.   Farhadinia, B., "A novel method of ranking hesitant fuzzy values for multiple attribute decision‐making problems", International Journal of Intelligent Systems,  Vol. 28, No. 8, (2013), 752-767.

41.   Yu, D., Zhang, W. and Xu, Y., "Group decision making under hesitant fuzzy environment with application to personnel evaluation", Knowledge-Based Systems,  Vol. 52,  (2013), 1-10.

42.   Wang, J. Q., Wang, D. D., yu Zhang, H. and Chen, X. H., "Multi-criteria outranking approach with hesitant fuzzy sets", OR Spectrum,  Vol. 36, No. 4, (2014), 1001-1019.

43.   Zhang, Y., Wang, Y. and Wang, J., "Objective attributes weights determining based on shannon information entropy in hesitant fuzzy multiple attribute decision making", Mathematical Problems in Engineering,  Vol. 2014, (2014).

44.   Rodriguez, R. M., Martinez, L., Torra, V., Xu, Z. and Herrera, F., "Hesitant fuzzy sets: State of the art and future directions", International Journal of Intelligent Systems,  Vol. 29, No. 6, (2014), 495-524.

45.   Lu, M. and Wei, G.-W., "Models for multiple attribute decision making with dual hesitant fuzzy uncertain linguistic information", International Journal of Knowledge-based and Intelligent Engineering Systems,  Vol. 20, No. 4, (2016), 217-227.

46.   Wei, G.-W., Xu, X.-R. and Deng, D.-X., "Interval-valued dual hesitant fuzzy linguistic geometric aggregation operators in multiple attribute decision making", International Journal of Knowledge-based and Intelligent Engineering Systems,  Vol. 20, No. 4, (2016), 189-196.

47.   Wei, G., "Interval valued hesitant fuzzy uncertain linguistic aggregation operators in multiple attribute decision making", International Journal of Machine Learning and Cybernetics,  Vol. 7, No. 6, (2016), 1093-1114.

48.   Wei, G., "Picture fuzzy cross-entropy for multiple attribute decision making problems", Journal of Business Economics and Management,  Vol. 17, No. 4, (2016), 491-502.

49.   Tang, Y., Wen, L.-L. and Wei, G.-W., "Approaches to multiple attribute group decision making based on the generalized dice similarity measures with intuitionistic fuzzy information", International Journal of Knowledge-based and Intelligent Engineering Systems,  Vol. 21, No. 2, (2017), 85-95.

50.   Chen, N., Xu, Z., and Xia, M., "Interval-valued hesitant preference relations and their applications to group decision making", Knowledge-Based Systems, Vol. 37, (2013), 528-540.

51.   Gitinavard, H., Mousavi, S., and Vahdani, B., "Soft computing-based new interval-valued hesitant fuzzy multi-criteria group assessment method with last aggregation to industrial decision problems", Soft Computing, (2015), 1-19.

52.   Farhadinia, B., Information measures for hesitant fuzzy sets and interval-valued hesitant fuzzy sets.Information Sciences, Vol. 240, (2013), 129-144.

53.   Mousavi, S. M., Gitinavard, H., and Siadat, A., "A new hesitant fuzzy analytical hierarchy process method for decision-making problems under uncertainty", in Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management (IEEM), IEEE International Conference on, (2014).

54. Gitinavard, H., Mousavi, S. M., and Vahdani, B., "Soft computing based on hierarchical evaluation approach and criteria interdependencies for energy decision-making problems: A case study", Energy, Vol. 118, (2017), 556-577.

55. Gitinavard H., Mousavi S. M., Vahdani B., and Siadat, A., "A distance-based decision model in interval-valued hesitant fuzzy setting for industrial selection problems", Scientia Iranica. Transaction E, Industrial Engineering, Vol. 23, No. 4, (2016), 1928-1940.

56. Gitinavard, H., Mousavi, S. M., and Vahdani, B., "A new multi-criteria weighting and ranking model for group decision-making analysis based on interval-valued hesitant fuzzy sets to selection problems", Neural Computing and Applications, Vol. 27, (2016), 1593–1605.

57.   Junior, F. R. L., Osiro, L., and Carpinetti, L. C. R., "A comparison between Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy TOPSIS methods to supplier selection", Applied Soft Computing, Vol. 21, (2014), 194-209.